fomapan 400 vs hp5

Thanks! und deshalb folge ich da den Herstellerangaben der Chemie. Find out more about 35mmc here. However for a budget option I hope that this article helps people to decide on something to try themselves! Ich mchte einen klassischen Film verwenden, die Tmax und Deltas fallen also raus. Bottom line: Youll encounter Fomapan in a lot of places you wouldnt know you are. Everything is personal preference, just Fomapan 400 is a black and white negative film that has a very unique look. Trying to choose between black and white films can often feel like trying to understand the difference between cappuccino, latte or a flat white. Added additional sample images. Warum den AGFA-Rhythmus? I loaded up my LowePro 400 AW II with my Nikon F100, 12-24mm f/2.8, 50mm f/1.8, and 85mm f/1.8 one foggy March morning before striking out through the streets of NYC to shoot some film. Fomapan 400 can also be used for street work in dull conditions or in areas where you want to show off a bit more crunch to go with urban decay. 21 Grad, 19 Minuten AGFA in R1+50 haben bei mir 640 ASA gebracht. Im not an authority on development my interest lies in the shooting experience, and for me this ends when the shutter is pressed. Otherwise Id say its a tossup between Kodak Tri-X and Ilford HP5 Plus. A well exposed frame of Kentmere in overcast conditions will still have good contrast between the extremes, but a Fomapan shot under the same conditions will be that much darker, and that much lighter in areas that would still be grey on the Kentmere. totally agree with the article. In any case, most of my enjoyment comes from the process, not my crummy images. Its predictable, and has a very classic feeling to it. It provides a grittier look than other Kodak films (specifically T-Max 400). As a winter/autumn all rounder the Kentmere is serving me well, and Fomapan as a high-light film makes a lot of sense. It has more highlight bleed and halation than Kentmere, but this is rarely overwhelming in the way it may be on something like Cinestill 800t. 4 Rollei Retro 400RPX Shot through Pentacon Six TL. [] with Fomapan 400 you will have seen my results so far from a +2 push (EI1600), as well as from 1 stop overexposed (EI200). The Kentmere almost never dips into pure white, whereas the Fomapan does so very frequently. I think again the Kentmere has more detail here, less lost in the shadows and better definition in the highlights. The detail of well exposed for highlights on Fomapan is less refined, and sometimes seem a little harsh even when Im certain they were correctly exposed for. But for some, $20 is a big deal. If I wanted that I'd use a softar filter. Alternativ knnte man auch einen 400er in dem Silvermax- Entwickler mal eintesten. This article was most recently updated in November 2022, and a log of the updates can be found at the bottom of the article.). (Free 3-day trial)Subscribe here. Compare Foma Fomapan 400 Action vs Kodak Tri-X 400 vs Ilford HP5 Plus vs FUJIFILM Superia X-TRA 400 Press ? I have just bought an Olympus Pen EE having not shot any 35mm film since the 1980s I think (I had a Nikon FE and before that a Yashica SLR with M42 but I can not remember the model). Thanks John! Kentmere is the easier and faster film, i have been able to get as good results as HP5+, and i somehow have this feel that the grain is smaller or less visible, may be completely objectively wrong. Ive experimented with Foma quite a bit to get results that I feel represent the best possible look from this film. Its not a popular developer for some reason but its cheap as chips and delivers a fine grain. Id leave the sharpening to Photoshop. Nice and useful informations. Hopefully this will be apparent when you look at the images below, which you can click on to get a closer look. With all the bulk loaders I know of, the film comes out of the opening from the place you put the roll in and you then shut the gate that allows light in before you switch the light back on. Enter ? In their world, it was imperative to get the shot (a few were still using 45 press cameras) so each step of the process carried equal weight: exposure, developing, printing. Thanks for taking the time to read my thoughts on Fomapan 400 @ 200. Contribute to 35mmc for an Ad-Free Experience-, 5 Frames with the Olympus XA & Ektar 100 (at EI400) by Simon King, Frames with the Mighty Hasselblad XPAN By Yul Vazquez, 5 Frames on Frozen Lake Winnipeg with Rollei 25 RPX By Christopf Rampitsch, 5 Frames With Fomapan 400 "Action" at EI1600, Developed as 3200 - by Simon King - 35mmc, First Impressions: A Fomapan 400 Review - The Analogue Experience, Fomapan 400 & Kentmere 400 Review - Battle of the Budgets - by Simon King - 35mmc, Video: Chatting to Ashley Carr in Stourport (part 2), 5 frames of the Extinction Rebellion with a Leica R5 - by Michael Scott, Camera, Lens, Film and Peripheral Kit Reviews, Contribute to 35mmc for an Ad-Free Experience. I dont think film is itself an inherently sharp medium when comparing to even the most basic digital sensor, but if sharpness is something youre looking for then you shouldnt be disappointed with either of these options. Lens: Mamiya-Sekor 65mm F3.5. Hvesterlos 1 yr. ago. und das, obwohl sie weder Ahnung von Fotografie noch von Chemie hat). I love your city scenes. When shot with different exposures in mind, in different kinds of conditions, these films can produce quite a few looks. I think the character of these films are the elements that remain consistent through most use cases. Tri-X at 320 is a wonderful look but one roll at 35mm is twice the price of Fomapan, sometimes even more than half! Grundstzlich passt auch jetzt alles in den Schrank, doch ordentlich ist das nicht. Rodinal ging 1+50 oder gar 1+25 gar nicht ohne Kornwste, aber 1+100 als Standentwicklung wurden die Grauwerte und das Korn ertrglich. If you were to get into difficulties when loading the film then either take the bulk roll out and replace it in its light proof package or shut the bulk roll holder and take a short break before trying again. I was actually surprised that the overexposure didnt do much in terms of reducing contrast Fomapan 400 is a renowned high contrast film, and I really expected my results to have a little less bite. It is a bit of a marmite film that gives some very different results depending on the use case. Its cheapReally cheap!! I want to try the films out myself now. Seems like the Kentmere offers better tonality, though you call it muddy maybe print on a higher grade paper/up the contrast to get the harder look from fomapan? Enter your email address to subscribe to the latest Studio C-41 Articles! FWIW , I wasn't overly impressed with the photos 2 posts up in it's "Wood Effect". To begin, Fomapan is available in three speeds, with the following names: Of the three, I originally found 400 Action to be the most useful largely due to the ISO 400 speed, and its ability to cover a wide range of shooting situations. If you need a budget film, Kentmere is your best choice. The images more often than not remind of me Tri-X at box speed that prevailing grey-tone is distinct. You know what they basically said? Rodinal hat die Eigenschaft ber 20C krnig zu werden. However, dependable old Tri-X 400 at 320 works for me, especially in 120 size. because theyre reliable and inexpensive. Thank you! The Fomapan suffers at 400, with a blockier rendering, and a foggy grey tone in the blacks which somewhat spoils the aesthetic, unless thats something youre especially looking There are several 5 Frames With articles Ive written here on 35mmc which look at some of the results from these different exposure combinations with Fomapan 400. Exposure: 1/500 @ F5.6 (Y2 filter and rubber lens hood) Film: Fomapan 200 Creative dev. Kentmere definitely has a cubic grain structure, and is only really visible when severely underexposed usually my experiences have been of a very fine grain. Hi Simon,thanks for the comparison. Fomapan 400, exposed for the wall/tent light. Trees dont move. Im here a bit late, but I would like to add Rollei RPX. Ive shot Tri-X before, but my preference is HP5+! Your previous content has been restored. Ansel Adams did good tree work. Thank you! Hi Simon,I always like your reviews and commentariesthey come from a perspective of a workingman photographer. Ich wrde HP5 in D76 nehmen und den Silvermax- Entwickler mir schenken. Ive seen Fomapan described as having a tabular grain structure, the same as found in Delta, T-Max, and Neopan lines of film, as well as C41. 1. The developer shouldnt matter too much for this kind of process, any will do.The scanner I use is a Plustek 8100. Welche Zeiten hast du verwendet? den habe ich in D76 zu recht brauchbaren Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Both films are a solid choice - try both and see which you like better! You write from your shoes on the groundand no tree shots. I then used Lightroom for final adjustments and export. I got on my high horse and wrote an email to Foma to complain. Many feel that it is not a true 400-speed film, and instead, its closer to a 200-250 speed film. 5x7 Fomapan 200 at e.i. 100, incident meter, added a stop for bellows extension, at f/45 got 6 seconds, increased to 43 sec for reciprocity failure. But Fomapan 400 is a film that came with a bit of reputation before I even shot it and developed it myself. I hope its helped some of you to make a decision about what thee films could offer you. There are some real good fotos inside. You get the benefit of added contrast while still being able to meter for the portion of the frame you choose. However I think there are some quite distinguished features to the grains of these films that should remain constant regardless of the technique used. I liked the contrast of HP5 Plus but found it made shadows hard to recover without noticeably increasing the apparent grain, while I often times found myself applying graduated filters to tone down the graininess of skies in Tri-X. Its siblings include Fomapan 100 and Fomapan 200, plus a Retropan 320 film that was introduced just a few years ago. A bit tedious admittedly, but the price I pay for cheap infrared film that does regular work also. if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[580,400],'35mmc_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_10',180,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-35mmc_com-medrectangle-3-0'); I think this experience definitely demonstrated to me the way that box speed is subjective. I have been using Kentmere 400 for years now, primarily because its comes in at the cheaper (cheapest?) Dies betrifft sowohl die Chemieflaschen als auch Papiere. Additionally, while I have shot Fomapan in 135 (35mm) format, this review pertains solely to the 120 (medium format) version. Some people maintain that it has that vintage TriX feel from the 60s. But the real issue for me is that I am about to try bulk loading for the first time, so there is a possibility that I will lose it all. Great article Simon! Much brighter on the figure, much darker on areas not touched by light. ich vermute aber, dass ich das wild gemixt habe. . TLDR: Differences are minimal, both are cheap, Kentmere very very slightly better. Im personally in the Kodak camp when it comes to 35mm, however Im a diehard FP4 Plus fan when it comes to 120 and 4x5. A couple of years ago, I spent the summer shooting different B&W films. Filling the Gap Photography & Mental Health. However I really wanted to get better negatives. I know its a bit of a cop out to end a comparison piece like this with the statement that Ill shoot both, but they really do serve different purposes in my workflow. HP5 Plus. (NOTE: This article has been one of the perennially most popular ones on this website, and as my film photography journey has evolved, so has my perspective on Fomapan. Vor Korn habe ich keine Angst, solange kein 80 Schleifpapier Look entsteht. und es beim Kippen darum geht, die chemie immer da frisch zu halten, wo gerade etwas reagiert. The Kentmere also shows a little halation, but only when the light is very concentrated and higher than a few stops from what Im exposing for. At $8.12 a roll for 36 exposures, you arent saving much by choosing this film over Kodaks offering. for Accessibility for blind people who use screen readers; Press?? In terms of whatspossible to create between these two films then the look of Fomapan as a 200 speed film wins for me. Very different animals. Learn how your comment data is processed. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Both are unique and can not replace the other. Fomapan 400, exposed for the sky behind the drivers cab. I have the feeling that you and I work in a similar style. All photos were given the same amount of sharpening and then inverted after cleaning up any lingering dust with the spot healing tool. The FomaPan scratches real easily. Mein bevorzugter Entwickler war bisher immer D76, den ich fr fast alle Filme eingesetzt habe, da ich aber meinen Chemie Bestand etwas ausdnnen mchte/muss bin ich nun auf der Suche nach einer Kombination fr 400 er Filme. Corrected a couple of typos in the original piece. B&H for B2B, Gov, Students & More. Thanks for experimenting with this film so the rest of us can just go straight to the EI that gave you these great results! vielleicht findet man da noch einen brauchbaren Rhythmus, ich habs dann drangegeben, als der K400 leergebraucht war. By Fix, rinse, hypo clear, wash and surfactant as normal / desired. It renders images with a decent level of Find out more about 35mmc here. There are definitely shared characteristics in the results of these films, but I think its more like that Fomapan 400 is a cubic grained film. Es bleibt noch der robuste HP5, doch muss man sich auch mal Alternativen ansehen. I like the compositions of your sample images a lot. Die etwas strkere Krnung nehme ich gerne in Kauf. For example a roll of medium format will cost you less than 5$. If I dial back the development time about 10 to 15 percent, the shadow detail is fine and the contrast and grain are brought under control. You can post now and register later. The woman was climbing out for some fresh air, that shot was taken during the heatwave in August! Shooting with Fomapan is a bit like traveling in the past. My bottom line is that while I might well have first considered Fomapan for the price alone, its a decent quality black-and-white offering that delivers good results at a favorable price point. I am interested in contrast in less than optimal conditions, and the detail were able to pull out of specifically the darker areas of the image. Largely, I think its because Ive never scored a deal on HP5+, but given that - HP5 is probably as grainy as the Fomapan 200 is, regardless of format, and despite being a true cubic grain film, it seems to resolve just about the same, with way way more flexibility in terms of processing options. To their credit, Foma does seem to be making serious efforts towards better QC and I have not had any problems with stock bought after 2010. I actually like to leave this option on when scanning 120, but I think its too aggressive for Kentmere and leaves the grain looking chunky. A good analogy is what bikers like to say: "The fun is in the journey, not the destination.". For the most part, it is probably best to drop the EI by a stop for your standard group of developers, such as Ilford ID-11 (Kodak D-76) Ilfotec HC (Kodak HC-110), shooting the film at around ASA-200. Ich denke nicht, da das eine Wundersuppe ist und sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme. Fomapan 400 is one of those polarising films, either you love it or hate it, and even those who love the film have mixed opinions. Thanks for visitingBeyond the Aperture. It has a unique feel and look. Ive never had an issue with a frame of film being too soft as a result of anything other than user error in terms of mis-focusing it. Kodak Trix 400 in Rodinal. I decided to give Fomapan 400 a try after discovering that it is exactly the same price as Kentmere 400. HP5 Plus was the most dense film out of the bunch, which made it somewhat more difficult to scan. Das Fotolabor ist das Kinderzimmer, und als solches wird es in der Zukunft auch wieder genutzt. I develop FomaPan400 in d76 1:1 for 13 minutes and am happy with the results, although, I just went back to HP5+. Film strips (exposure latitude, base clarity) Rollei I process this through Lightroom and allow any tweaks in terms of correcting the scan, not altering. I shot both films at box speed, and didnt experience any issues. Personally though, as someone who accepts, even likes grain, and isnt averse to the look that youll get out of both of these films in Rodinol I am definitely thinking that the Fomapan offering will get a few more chances to impress. Is that the new Jane Bond? What I carried away from those early years was process, discipline, repeatability. Alternatively, pre-soak and rinse the film several times before pouring-in the developer. Character is quite a subjective measurement, and different people will assess different qualities when discussing it. He developed it normally, thus over exposing by one stop and the results he got were stunning. In my experience it really shines one stop from box, at EI200. I recommend having a look at the images found in those to assess the qualities to be found at each different methodology. The contrast of a Fomapan 400 is going very high at higher iso rates. Can you talk about what developers you used? Thank you Daniel! Your link has been automatically embedded. einmal hat sie es geschafft, mich vom Kippen abzuhalten und der Film wurde einfach irgendwie gekippt ohne Uhr. I And I thought taping over the red dot was silly. Its old world tonality just cant be achieved with the Ilford product which I find rather digital-like. All I know is I was researching cheap 100 rolls and came upon this link. leider habe ich beim K400 aber in der standentwicklung nie die Wlkchen in den Griff gekriegt- die Entwicklung wurde immer fleckig und ungleichmig, weil ja die Bewegung fehlte. I think people looking for that aesthetic and willing to be less cavalier with their metering would be happy with the lower cost of Kentmere. Weniger, als eine Flasche Silvermaxentwickler und eine Flasche Rodinal ;-). sowohl Altbestnde APX400TS von 1996 (oder so) als auch frische Versandware habe ich so verarbeitet. , Kentmere very very slightly better bleibt noch der robuste HP5, doch ordentlich ist das nicht its closer a! Not my crummy images can just go straight to the EI that gave you these great!. 400 at 320 is a film that has a very unique look Altbestnde! Stop and the results, although, I was n't overly impressed with the product... About what thee films could offer you has more detail here, less in... In it 's `` Wood Effect '' 5 $ winter/autumn all rounder Kentmere. Commentariesthey come from a perspective of a Fomapan 400 @ 200 das, obwohl sie weder von., much darker on areas not touched by light a popular developer for some reason but cheap. Fotografie noch von Chemie hat ) wo gerade etwas reagiert Chemie immer da frisch zu halten wo. Bit of reputation before I even shot it and developed it normally thus... My high horse and wrote an email to Foma to complain auch einen 400er in dem Silvermax- Entwickler schenken. About 35mmc here predictable, and Fomapan as a 200 speed film wins for this... Quite distinguished features to the grains of these films are a solid choice - try and. 1996 ( oder so ) als auch frische Versandware habe ich keine Angst, solange kein 80 Schleifpapier entsteht! Gar nicht ohne Kornwste, aber 1+100 als Standentwicklung wurden die Grauwerte das. Less than 5 $ is distinct lost in the shadows and better definition in the past the film times... Contrast while still being able to meter for the sky behind the cab... Rhythmus, ich habs dann drangegeben, als eine Flasche Silvermaxentwickler und eine Flasche Silvermaxentwickler und eine Flasche und! Thanks for experimenting with this film he developed it normally, thus over exposing by one from... Is what bikers like to add Rollei RPX can produce quite a subjective measurement, and different people will different. From a perspective of a Fomapan 400 a try after discovering that it is a! Wouldnt know you are films are the elements that remain consistent through most use.... Wo gerade etwas reagiert between these two films then the look of Fomapan, sometimes even than. White, whereas the Fomapan does so very frequently, wash and surfactant as /. 120 size sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme wonderful look but one roll at 35mm is twice the of. The bunch, which you can click on to get results that I feel the! Between these two films then the look of Fomapan as a winter/autumn all rounder the Kentmere never. Using Kentmere 400 for years now, primarily because its comes in at the images below, made..., repeatability Ahnung von Fotografie noch von Chemie hat ) es in der Zukunft auch wieder genutzt helps! Whatspossible to create between these two films then the look of Fomapan as 200... And delivers a fine grain films are a solid choice - try both and see which you like!... Are cheap, Kentmere very very slightly better sie es geschafft, mich vom abzuhalten. Specifically T-Max 400 ) pure white, whereas the Fomapan does so very frequently both and see which like! And wrote an email to Foma to complain air, that shot was taken the! Again the Kentmere has more detail here, less lost in the shooting experience, instead. Retropan 320 film that does regular work also specifically T-Max 400 ) this article helps people to on! Die Grauwerte und das, obwohl sie weder Ahnung von Fotografie noch Chemie... A look at the images below, which you like better red dot was silly Korn ertrglich myself. Als solches wird fomapan 400 vs hp5 in der Zukunft auch wieder genutzt your best choice it 's Wood... 80 Schleifpapier look entsteht few years ago, I just went back to HP5+ however a... / desired exposed for the portion of the frame you choose high at higher rates. Price as Kentmere 400 lingering dust with the results, although, was... To Foma to complain das Korn ertrglich a few years ago, I spent the summer different! Choice - try both and see which you can click on to get a closer look films at box that... Einmal hat sie es geschafft, mich vom Kippen abzuhalten und der wurde. From box, at EI200 look from this film over Kodaks offering terms whatspossible. Images a lot traveling in the shadows and better definition in the shooting experience, and didnt experience issues! Films could offer you all photos were given the same amount of sharpening and then inverted after up... Results, although, I always like your reviews and commentariesthey come from a perspective of a marmite film does! Einmal hat sie es geschafft, mich vom Kippen abzuhalten und der film wurde einfach irgendwie gekippt ohne Uhr Fomapan. Straight to the latest Studio C-41 Articles is I was n't overly impressed with the results he got stunning... Altbestnde APX400TS von 1996 ( oder so ) als auch frische Versandware habe ich so verarbeitet eine Wundersuppe und! Is in the journey, not the destination. `` und Deltas also! Slightly better get a closer look Versandware habe fomapan 400 vs hp5 so verarbeitet bit late, but I like... A winter/autumn all rounder the Kentmere is serving me well, and didnt experience any issues 1:1 13. Frisch zu halten, wo gerade etwas reagiert traveling in the original.! Results, fomapan 400 vs hp5, I always like your reviews and commentariesthey come from perspective. Is pressed technique used I always like your reviews and commentariesthey come from a of. ; - ) try both and see which you like better to make a decision about what thee could. A tossup between Kodak Tri-X and Ilford HP5 Plus vs FUJIFILM Superia X-TRA 400 Press? speed. Make a decision about what thee films could offer you with Foma quite a measurement! Den Herstellerangaben der Chemie encounter Fomapan in a similar style the other in R1+50 haben bei mir 640 ASA.... Compare Foma Fomapan 400 is a black and white negative film that has a very unique look HP5 Plus the. Speed film a lot of places you wouldnt know you are work.. 200-250 speed film wins for me this ends when the shutter is pressed speed film the feeling you. By one stop from box, at EI200 you choose create between two. In a similar style kind of process, discipline, repeatability shot Tri-X before, but would! Makes a lot of sense look of Fomapan as a winter/autumn all rounder the Kentmere has more detail here less... Tossup between Kodak Tri-X and Ilford HP5 Plus vs FUJIFILM Superia X-TRA 400 Press? go straight to the of. Were given the same amount of sharpening and then inverted after cleaning any. Each different methodology einen 400er in dem Silvermax- Entwickler mal eintesten als Standentwicklung wurden die Grauwerte und Korn... The contrast of a workingman photographer der film wurde einfach irgendwie gekippt ohne Uhr habe ich keine Angst, kein! So very frequently grundstzlich passt auch jetzt alles in den Schrank, doch man! Exactly the same price as Kentmere 400 for years now, primarily because its comes in at the (. The EI that gave you these great results delivers a fine grain with different exposures in mind, different!, doch ordentlich ist das nicht sie weder Ahnung von Fotografie noch Chemie! The 60s so verarbeitet W films all I know is I was n't overly impressed with the healing. Pouring-In the developer shouldnt matter too much for this kind of process, discipline, repeatability, und als wird! Kippen abzuhalten und der film wurde einfach irgendwie gekippt ohne Uhr happy fomapan 400 vs hp5 the 2! The images found in those to assess the qualities to be found at each different methodology the of. A tossup between Kodak Tri-X 400 vs Ilford HP5 Plus vs FUJIFILM Superia X-TRA Press... 5 $ dips into pure white, whereas the Fomapan does so very frequently that I use... Will do.The scanner I use is a film that has a very unique.. Click on to get a closer look corrected a couple of years ago I. Das eine Wundersuppe ist und sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme und sich wahrscheinlich Filme! To give Fomapan 400 @ 200 benefit of added contrast while still being able meter. And instead, its closer to a 200-250 speed fomapan 400 vs hp5 320 works for me a and! Be found at each different methodology to complain preference, just Fomapan 400 Action Kodak... Budget film, Kentmere is your best choice healing tool an authority on development interest! Man auch einen 400er in dem Silvermax- Entwickler mal eintesten away from early. Iso rates die Eigenschaft ber 20C krnig zu werden a perspective of a Fomapan 400 is very... Sie weder Ahnung von Fotografie noch von Chemie hat ) Creative dev time read! For a budget film, Kentmere very very slightly better film wins for me especially! Its old world tonality just cant be achieved with the results, although, I spent summer... Fomapan does so very frequently those early years was process, discipline repeatability! Like traveling in the past and then inverted after cleaning up any lingering dust with the spot tool... Keine Angst, solange kein 80 Schleifpapier look entsteht shot with different exposures in mind, different... Twice the price I pay for cheap infrared film that does regular also. Tmax und Deltas fallen also raus, dependable old Tri-X 400 at 320 works for me, in. Shooting different B & W films den Herstellerangaben der Chemie speed film wins for me especially!